Download
The method

How to solve a case

Solving a mystery is not about gut feeling. It is work you do in steps, and you can learn it. This is the method that works on Half Story cases, and it works with a crime novel or a board game too.

1. Reread the beginning

The beginning of a case holds more than it seems: the names of the people, the places, a time, a detail out of place. The first time, you read to understand what happened. The second time, you read to mark what does not add up.

Make a short list: who was there, where, and at what time. You will need it later.

2. Separate facts from claims

A fact can be checked: a log, a receipt, a camera, a time. A claim is what someone says. People get things wrong, remember badly or lie; a document almost never does.

When two sources say different things, do not decide straight away who is right. Mark the spot: there is almost always something there. The newspaper is a claim too: it tells the city's version, which is not always the true one.

3. Follow times and places

Whoever did it had to be in the right place at the right time. Put the times you know in order and look for someone with a gap: an hour with no witnesses, a journey that does not work, a door that was open when it should have been shut.

4. Look for the liar, not the unpleasant one

The rudest suspect is usually just rude. What matters is who says something that a fact contradicts.

In Half Story cases nobody confesses: whoever lies keeps lying even when faced with the evidence. It is up to you to notice that the two things do not fit together.

5. Rule things out

Half the work is setting aside what has nothing to do with the case. A place that leads nowhere, a person with a checked alibi: mark them and let them go. The fewer leads you keep open, the clearer the right one becomes.

In Half Story you can mark a place as irrelevant: it leaves your list and stops distracting you.

6. Check the motive before you answer

You have a name. Before you write it, ask yourself why that person would have done it, and whether every fact on your list fits. If one is left that you cannot explain, go back: that is usually where the mistake is.

In Half Story the questions of the report come one at a time, and each one builds on the one before. A wrong answer ends the attempt, and you can try again after five minutes: it is worth answering only when the whole story holds up.

Try it on a case

You learn the method by using it. Right here in your browser there is a small case you can solve in five minutes, with the real rules. Then every Monday a new one comes out in the app.